Israeli consul attacks Spielberg's Munich as 'problematic'

Publié le par David CASTEL

Gary Younge in New York
Monday December 12, 2005
The Guardian

Israel's consul-general in Los Angeles has lambasted Steven Spielberg's film about the 1972 Olympic massacre in Munich as a "superficial", "pretentious" and "problematic" work that draws an incorrect moral equation between Mossad agents and Palestinian terrorists.

Speaking to Israeli radio, Ehud Danoch, said: "As a Hollywood movie, I assume that it will be defined as a well-made film, but from the standpoint of the messages it sends, the messages are problematic."

Munich follows a hit squad from the Israeli secret service, Mossad, as it hunts down and kills the gunmen from the Palestinian Black September group who held hostage Israeli athletes during the Olympics. A botched rescue operation by German security forces ended in 11 of the athletes being killed.

Accusing Oscar-winning Spielberg of equating Mossad agents to the terrorists, Mr Danoch argued: "This is an incorrect moral equation. We in Israel know this. There is also a certain pretentiousness in attempting to treat a painful decades-long conflict by means of quite superficial statements in a movie."

The criticism is likely to disappoint Spielberg, who last week described his film to Time magazine as a "prayer for peace", insisting that the biggest threat to the Middle East was neither the Palestinians nor the Israelis but intransigence on both sides. "I wanted this film to be in memory of [the Israeli athletes] because they seem to have been forgotten," he told Time. "The silence about them by the International Olympic Committee is getting louder for me every four years."

But far from fostering reconciliation, early screenings have triggered considerable criticism from Israeli hardliners. "Jews pioneered Hollywood," wrote Jack Engelhard, the author of the best-selling novel and film, Indecent Proposal, on the Tel-Aviv-based website, "If, as our enemies say, we own Hollywood, well, here's the plot twist - we have lost Hollywood, and we have lost Spielberg. Spielberg is no friend of Israel. Spielberg is no friend of truth. His Munich may just as well have been scripted by George Gallo

Special report Israel and the Middle East

  Search this site



2001 part one

2001 part two

2002 part one

2002 part two

2002 part three

2002 part four, 2003


Go to...

Special report: Israel and the Middle East

Israel and the Middle East articles archive

Audio reports from Israel

 In this section
Israeli consul attacks Spielberg's Munich as 'problematic'

The Observer book aid appeal

Papers reveal UK's nuclear aid to Israel

Calls grow for withdrawal of Nobel prize

Life under siege in a divided city

Israel should move to Europe, says Iran's leader

Syria ready to reopen Israel peace talks

Gerald Kaufman: The Gaza withdrawal has been a veil for continued persecution and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians

Air strike kills Palestinian militant

Five killed as suicide bomber strikes in Israel

Spielberg hopes to use film to connect Israelis and Palestinians

Ex-US diplomat blames Israel for Pakistani dictator's death

Five killed in Israeli shopping centre blast

Iran plans new nuclear reactor

Peres defends his breakaway with Sharon

Publié dans Réactions en Israël

Commenter cet article